Tag Archives: justification

Is Original Sin a Legal Fiction?

scenarioB_v2.1

Lane Keister responds to Roman Catholic criticisms that justification by faith alone depends on an understanding of the imputed righteousness of Christ that turns salvation into a “legal fiction” — we are righteous but not really because, in the words of John Kinnaird, it is not real and personal. That post got me wondering about… Read More→

Posted in Application of Redemption, Forensics, Reformed Protestantism, Roman Catholicism, The Hinge | Also tagged , | 21 Responses

What a Difference Three Decades Make

1981__720__sandra_day_oconnor_1

In 1981 the PCA turned down the OPC’s decision to join the PCA. The context was something called J&R, joining and receiving. The PCA had invited the RPCES (denominational patron of Covenant College and Covenant Seminary) and the OPC to join and be received by the PCA into one denomination. The RPCES cleared the hurdle.… Read More→

Posted in Forensics | Also tagged , , , , | 56 Responses

Are Protestants Logocentric? Proudly (in a humble way)

128756_imagno

From Luther’s comments on John 3: What should Christ do, and of what use is the Messiah? What kind of Messiah is He? . . . What does He do? He testifies. If He walks in such weakness and holds on His kingdship no more fimrly than that He testified, is there nothing else that… Read More→

Posted in Adventures in Church History, Are the CTCers Paying Attention? | Also tagged , , , , | 16 Responses

Former Saint’s Remorse

All-Saints-Day

News is circulating that Jason Stellman has finally made official what many surmised — converted to Roman Catholicism. The link to his piece is now dead, which may suggest a vast right-wing Protestant conspiracy. But various bloggers — eager beavers that they are — have offered extensive comments on various quotes from Stellman’s first public… Read More→

Posted in Application of Redemption | Also tagged , , , | 249 Responses

How 2K Might Have Helped Stellman

Rocky-Road-Brownies

I hope Jason Stellman does not consider this piling on. He is a friend and I mean to be respectful of his decision even if I lament his loss of Protestant convictions. At the same time, since some have invoked the two-kingdoms theology as a plausible factor in Stellman’s resignation, a response is in order.… Read More→

Posted in spirituality of the church | Also tagged , , , , | 94 Responses

The Hits Keep Coming

Mad Men

Just when I was recovering from the sobering news of Jason Stellman’s decision to leave the PCA along comes Carl Trueman’s double-whammy of heaping scorn upon those “for whom the doctrine of the church and 2K are all they ever seem to talk about.” (For Stellman’s response, go here.) Trueman’s is a remarkable performance since… Read More→

Posted in High Church Presbyterianism, Reformed Protestantism | Also tagged , , , , , , | 31 Responses

Where’s Waldo Wednesday: Precision Puh-leeze

So why is it that justification prioritists (JPs) regularly receive the charge of making justification the CAUSE of sanctification when in fact they don’t? But to the unionists’ ear, to assert the logical priority of justification to sanctification (and no cheating by sneaking in definitive sanctification) is to say that justification CAUSES sanctification (often, anyway).… Read More→

Posted in Application of Redemption | Also tagged , , , | 52 Responses

Where’s Waldo Wednesday: Dazed and Confused

Why is it that discussions of the law and sanctification invariably circle back to union with Christ? My own hunch, expressed several times, is that union becomes the way to cement sanctification to justification, especially if neither is prior to the other but union precedes both. This way, supposedly, Protestants can look Roman Catholics straight… Read More→

Posted in Application of Redemption, The Hinge | Also tagged , , , , , | 48 Responses

Where’s Waldo (A Day After) Wednesday: Someone Needs to Call A Union Summit

Over at Justin Taylor’s blog comes word that Dane Ortlund has published an article on the relationship between justification and sanctification in the writings of Bavinck and Berkouwer. The summary point is as follows: . . . these two Dutch Reformed thinkers are united in their understanding of justification as the self-conscious means of sanctification.… Read More→

Posted in Application of Redemption | Also tagged , , , , , | 32 Responses

Where’s Waldo Wednesday: Can Union Comfort the Way Justification Does?

The following passage from Luther’s daily readings left me thinking: What more could God do? How could a heart restrain itself from being happy, glad, and obedient in God and Christ? What work or suffering could befall to which it would not gladly submit, singing with love and joyful praise to God? If it fails… Read More→

Posted in Application of Redemption | Also tagged , | 81 Responses