We only want to watch it (sometimes).
That’s one thought that came to me when reading this (thanks to another of our southern correspondents):
During the eight years of the Obama administration, white evangelical Christians, who make up one-quarter of the U.S. population, felt that culture moving away from them. They watched gay marriage become the law of the land and Christians come under fire for saying they didn’t want to provide pizzas or cakes or photographs for those weddings. They heard college students demand “safe spaces” and “trigger warnings”; they heard “Black Lives Matter” and didn’t understand when they were demonized for responding “All Lives Matter.” Their president disparaged people like them who “cling to guns or religion,” and then said that religious employers should subsidize their workers’ birth control and anyone should use any bathroom they like.
But if evangelical Christians are like me, they watch a lot of television and should know that the rest of America doesn’t live as evangelical Christians do.
Even so, television is one thing, society is another.
And let’s think about what drove that whitelash. This kind of thing often happens when groups and identities feel under threat. We know this from history. And it mirrors developments in Europe, especially in the face of globalization and an influx of culturally-distinct immigrants.
Evangelicals and other Americans may have sensed that television shows were becoming the reality. When the President approves of rainbow lights on the White House after SCOTUS legalizes gay marriage, and then he sends letters that micromanage states’ bathroom policies, you begin to worry that you have entered Girls — get this — without your consent.
but things now have changed, or will change at least before Jesus can come
John Frame–“The historia salutis expresses …integration between law and gospel …The gospel, the good news, is “Your God reigns” (Isa. 52:7). It is “the time has come, the kingdom of God is near. Repent and believe the good news” (Mark 1:15). This is gospel, because it is good news. But it is also law, because it is the coming of a king, the imposition of his rule.”
http://frame-poythress.org/salvation-and-theological-pedagogy/
John Frame– “The historia salutis method is that it sees salvation less in individual terms, more in corporate terms. The covenants are made, not only with the covenant mediators like Noah and Abraham, but through them with their families. By the time of Moses, the family of God had become a nation; and with the institution of the New Covenant, it became a nation made of many nations. The corporate emphasis in the historia salutis leads to a focus on the public and visible aspects of salvation. The events described in the ordo are invisible, inward. They occur in the individual heart. The historia salutis occurs in public events. The covenants are publicly witnessed. God attests his covenant mediators by signs and wonders. The history includes deliverances from oppressors, victories in war, dramatic displays of divine power and grace….. These are holy wars, and God promises Victory to Israel when she is faithful to him. John the Baptist, and later Jesus, preached “Repent, for the Kingdom of God is at hand.” The apostolic church preached “Jesus is Lord,” Kyrios Iesous, a phrase with a deeply political meaning. The Roman emperors proclaimed their own Lordship; the Christians proclaim the Lordship of Jesus. The Romans crucified Jesus, and later persecuted the church, because they thought Jesus presented himself as a rival Caesar…. The mission of the church was nothing less than to establish a NEW WORLD ORDER.”
LikeLike
Romanists may still have Jesus still dying on the cross, but they are not immune to being triumphalist in denouncing Calvinist triumphalism—–“Certainly in American evangelicalism, with its roots in Calvinism, there is a strong but perverted prosperity gospel tradition, which sees wealth and worldly success as a sign of divine blessing. It is no surprise that this tradition so easily embraced the libertarian ideology that became Republican orthodoxy. Catholics don’t have this excuse, of course,”
Does that mean that Franklin Graham is a “Calvinist”?
https://hellochristian.com/5113-franklin-graham-the-lord-saved-us-from-a-godless-atheistic-agenda
LikeLike
WHO is Lena Dunham? The New Republic explains in this sometimes toxic rant —
https://newrepublic.com/article/138624/hillary-clintons-celebrity-feminism-failure
LikeLike
Maybe not only the Left needs safe spaces… Our brave new world? Bartender, I’ll have another
LikeLike
The idea of the Black Lives Matter label is not to imply that other lives do not, but to emphasize that Black lives tend to be more at risk than the lives of those from other groups. It is like saying all houses matter but the house that needs attention is the one that is on fire.
As I talk to people and some of them include my friends, there is resistance to the idea that Black lives tend to face a more precarious situation especially from how law enforcement treats them than Whites do. There is this resistance to the idea that we still have systemic racism.
One way to determine whether systemic racism still exists would be to take an inductive approach by interviewing or reading about an adequately sized sample space of Blacks to examine what their experiences have been. But many of the white Christians I converse with are too myopic in this matter to use a large enough sample size.
Usually myopia is not a fatal condition. But when it affects the leaders and public policies we vote for and support, myopia can contribute to the self-destruction of any community.
LikeLike
Curt, please explain the difference between systemic racism circa 1950 when the U.S. had no black mayors, police chiefs, or presidents, and systemic racism in 2015. Guys like you don’t seem capable of noticing that some things changed. Those changes haven’t done much for folks at the lower end of the socio-economic ladder, blacks in Chicago’s South Side and whites in Hillsdale.
LikeLike
And what president of a Reformed seminary chain would have done this in 1950? At a theology conference no less.
LikeLike
cw, doesn’t matter. Jemar is still hurt.
LikeLike
D.G.,
Are you saying that because racism today is not identical to that which existed before, there is no systemic racism today? Better than answering your question, why expand your horizons and talk to a variety of Blacks about today’s racism. I’m sure you will get a variety of answers. But you will get a better understanding from hem than you will from me. And doing so would be consistent with what I wrote.
LikeLike
Curt, another anecdotal approach would be too listen to some white reasoning for voting Trump, which includes some variation on “we’re becoming the minority,” which whatever else that suggests it also seems to imply that there is indeed some sort of white privilege, contra what white Know-Nothings tend to say about WP. IOW, why worry about a reversal of fortune if as you say there is no fortune to begin with?
Not that I’m egalitarian; human societies naturally work in uneven ways. What is interesting is how the Know-Nothings give themselves away in some of their Trump-a-teering.
LikeLike
Curt, I listen to Glenn Loury and John McWhorter all the time. You?
LikeLike
Tough times for people who believe and say 50 times a day that a Tweet (or a line on a late night monologue) can TOTALLY DESTROY someone.
LikeLike
Peter Berger—“The immediate political effect of the Reformation was that Protestantism became the state religion in many parts of modern Europe—Lutheranism in Germany and Scandinavia, parts of Switzerland, England, and Scotland. The full impact of Protestantism only made itself felt in churches that were not established by the state—so-called “free churches” (such as Methodists and Baptists), some of them Evangelical or Pietist conventicles within state churches (such as the “low church” in England or the “wee kirk” in Scotland). Weber saw the importance of these groups (he misleadingly called them “sects”). It was in this environment that emerged the powerful combination of two phenomena—religious pluralism and religious freedom, particularly in the Netherlands, in Britain (the “Nonformists”), and most explosively in the United States. The American church historian Richard Niebuhr proposed that this development produced a new social form of religion—the “denomination,” http://www.the-american-interest.com/2016/11/10/is-the-world-becoming-protestant/
LikeLike
Those on the left always point to how much racism there was pre-1960s. And yet the black family in some very significant ways was doing much better than today after decades of the Left’s policy solutions and Democrat governance in most major cities. Implicit racism? Institutionalized racism? These are put forth as unassailable critiques. I think they are mostly empty if not useful vessels into which some pour subjective content in order to generally assign blame and demonize rather than diagnose the problems.
And two parent families for whites has dropped a lot while out of wedlock births for whites has gone way up. Studies have shown that one of the main if not the number one determinant leading to poverty is single parent homes and out of wedlock births. If white racism was they main problem then why are the same ailments found in both communities?
LikeLike
Dr. Hart — do McWhorter and Lowry bear the Anthony Bradley seal of approval? I admire Sowell and Walter E. Williams but A.B. told me that they couldn’t teach white people about the black experience??? Yet, like bro. Leon, they too have been black all their lives. So confusing.
LikeLiked by 1 person
D.G.,
I could add them to my list if that would make you happy. I actually like reading people from Martin Luther King to Joseph Lowery to Bill Fletcher to Bobby Seale. But I also read politically conservative Blacks whose writings I happen upon on the internet
But my feeling is that one must include in their sample space an adequate number of Blacks from all sorts economic classes and vocations. I vividly remember the stories a former colleague of mine told from the experiences of his adopted Black son and how he was constantly the target of racial profiling. And then there were the stories of those I protested with when we protested Stop and Frisk in NY City or the stories of those Blacks I’ve conversed while traveling.
So how big is your sample space? Because the validity of anyone’s findings depends on the randomness and size of the sample space they are using.
LikeLike
Jack, gay marriage will fix it. Celebrate equality and freedom! Do it!
LikeLike
Paul, imagine that. Black privilege.
LikeLike
Curt, you mean reading Ta Nehisi Coates or following BLM through mainstream media is not an accurate sample? psshaw.
LikeLike
D.G.,
Again, an adequate sample size usually includes a random sampling from public figures and groups to private individuals and the sampling includes those who have varying perspectives. So go out into your neighborhood and listen to the stories of your Black neighbors as well as the read the commentaries and stories of the people you have mentioned.
LikeLike
Curt, that’ll be hard:
LikeLike
D.G.,
Difficult does not equal impossible. It’s great to read well-known people and experts. But nothing gives a complete picture like adding to that conversations with everyday people. BTW, I get some of my info from talking to people while I travel.
LikeLike
Curt, you haven’t talked to me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anthony Bourdain confesses:
Problem is, it’s not their humanity. It’s the citizenship. Are they part of the country and as such do they have a say, or are they simply tax payers to be governed by graduates of the Kennedy School of Government?
LikeLike
Damon Linker offers perspective for which anti-Trump historians can only long:
LikeLike
Before “Girls,” “Friends.” See?
But to discredit President Trump, we turn Victorian.
LikeLike
Imagine if Donald Trump is doing to White House what Lena Dunham did to television:
Imagine thinking about Donald Trump.
LikeLike
Alt-right is scary, but alt-left is silly:
Meryl Streep’s speech was silly. Did anyone at WaPo, NYTimes, or New Yorker say so?
Gate keepers none.
LikeLike