Mencken’s line about fundamentalism would now seem to apply to Calvinism:
ROBERT FAW, correspondent: From baptism by immersion to the fervent Bible-based preaching, Sojourn Community Church in Louisville, Kentucky, looks and sounds like many other Southern Baptist congregations. What you cannot see, however, is that this Baptist church is infused with Calvinism—the teachings of a 16th-century Swiss theologian, John Calvin, whose tenets were practiced by America’s Puritans in the 17th and 18th century. . . .
FAW: Professor Rhyne Putnam teaches at the New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary and says many young people are attracted to Calvinism.
PROFESSOR RHYNE PUTNAM: I think there’s a sense where you have a kind of comfort that God is in control of things. We have a generation that really longs to go into deeper analysis of theology and deeper analysis of biblical studies.
FAW: It’s more intellectual.
PUTNAM: Right, I think so. It tends to be a little bit more heady than some of the more affective and kind of emotive kind of preaching.
FAW: Another reason for the explosive growth: charismatic proponents and prolific authors like Dr. Albert Mohler.
MOHLER: Calvinism offers a theological understanding of culture that many other theological systems just do not offer. Here you have people who are saying, “I want to go all the way back to where i can find something stable.”
Oh, by the way, Calvinism is also political:
Gordon Graham, director of the Abraham Kuyper Center for Public Theology, linked to Princeton University’s theology seminar, sees other reasons for this revival. “Mainstream Christian churches have become weak by embracing progressive causes like abortion and same-sex marriage. Neo-Calvinism is an answer to this.”
According to Isabelle Graesslé, head of the International Museum of the Reformation in Geneva, Calvinism advocates an individual conversion, personal salvation and the power of the Holy Spirit. Some Calvinists even consider the World Council of Churches, based in Geneva, as “some sort of new Antichrist.”
Mistrust of the state
American Calvinism is, of course, not new. It was very much a part of the early history of the United States. Its influence was considerable as soon as the Pilgrim Fathers, the English puritans who had found refuge in the Netherlands, reached Massachusetts in the 17th century. They founded universities, including the Calvin College in Michigan. “Their intellectual relation to America had a real impact,” Gordon Graham notes. Many credit them with the famous American spirit of individualism, the work ethic and even the American dream.
Even though neo-Calvinists are not directly involved in politics, they tend to be opposed to big government, a state that is too intrusive. Graham, for example, says the Patriot Act, the anti-terrorism law adopted by Congress after 9/11, is thoroughly contrary to Calvinist principles.
“Every sphere of life obeys to the sovereignty of God,” Graham says. “Calvinists don’t like the state intervening to standardize everything or to monitor people.”
Needless to say, they were outraged to learn that the National Security Agency was monitoring the Internet activity and telephone conversations of innocent Americans.
So with Calvinism you get divine sovereignty, intellectual heft, cultural savvy, American patriotism, and male headship. If you want to grow Lutherans (or at least gain publicity), take note.
Old Life 
Whither the R-word? Whither connectional churches with biblical worship?
LikeLike
Cw, that would require hitting a target.
LikeLike
You don’t say?
He just might be on to something there..
LikeLike
Learn something new every day around here.
Worth the price of admission, this blog. Yo.
LikeLike
In less than one generation a motley crew of evanjellycals, neo-Edwardsians, Piperians, SBCers with Macs and turtlenecks, congregationalists, independents, Kuyperians, and semi-charismatics have hijacked Calvinism. And they’re working on the R-word. Maybe it’s time to re-brand, go back to the original French spelling — Cauvinism.
LikeLike
Yeah! We’re winning. We have Tigerblood in us after all. Woohoo! Drugs and goddesses for everyone.
LikeLike
Reformed is great for that kid in Calculus who did the homework as taught, and then went to first principles to solve many problems, even one time came up with a solution that the teacher didn’t know about because it wasn’t in the answer book.
LikeLike
Sean, and twilight rates during the summer, never forget.
Fore!
LikeLike
Maybe we could call Reformed confessionalism Biblical Christianity. Has anyone claimed that name yet?
LikeLike
“American Calvinism is, of course, not new. It was very much a part of the early history of the United States. Its influence was considerable as soon as the Pilgrim Fathers, the English puritans who had found refuge in the Netherlands, reached Massachusetts in the 17th century. They founded universities, including the Calvin College in Michigan. ”
Lumper.
LikeLike
I take issue with the idea of Congregationalists being lumped in together with wannabes and theological hipsters jumping on the Reformed bandwagon . While is true that a good many Congregationalists are extremely liberal theologically or some are “Evanjellyfish” many of us who are Congregationalists have kept the Reformed faith. My own Congrgational Church was gathered in 1700, by gasp! ACTUAL living breaathing Puritans, and with some ups and downs in the course of time retained the Reformed faith, our Church statement of faith is the Westminster Shorter Catechism and the Savoy Declaration.
LikeLike
j12, “While is true that a good many Congregationalists are extremely liberal theologically or some are “Evanjellyfish” many of us who are Congregationalists have kept the Reformed faith.”
Glad to hear but I don’t think you have many in each category, especially when there are “many” Congregationalists – period.
LikeLike
Juriste:
Webite link?
You may be the fossiled remnant I’ve been seeking for a year-and-a-half.
This is like finally finding the Loch Ness Monster…
LikeLike
Juriste, that’s small “c” congregationalists – – meaning mostly baptists, non-presbys.
LikeLike