. . . you can believe almost anything.
Struck down on Good Friday, Lincoln, like Jesus, was viewed as a martyr who shed his blood and offered a redeeming sacrifice. Orators, editors, ministers, and statesmen across the North exalted Lincoln as the “savior of his country,” and sermons two days later on “Black Easter” and subsequent Sundays frequently compared Lincoln with Washington and Jesus. While Washington was the nation’s founder and father, ministers averred, Lincoln was its restorer and redeemer. While Christ died so that people could enjoy heaven, Lincoln died so they could have a better life on earth.
In making Lincoln the nation’s redeemer, ministers had to surmount two major difficulties: first, that he was fatally shot in a theater, an embarrassingly unsanctified place for a savior during the Victorian era. The clergy rationalized his attendance at Ford Theater, arguing that he had gone reluctantly to please his wife and gratify others.
The second, larger difficulty these pastors encountered was that Lincoln had never explicitly testified to his faith in Christ. While some pastors bitterly regretted that he did not publicly profess faith in Jesus Christ as his Lord, others countered that his actions demonstrated his faith or that he had accepted Christ as his savior in response to his son Willie’s death in 1862, or at Gettysburg in 1863, or at some other unknown time.
In their funeral sermons at Washington and Springfield respectively, the two ministers who knew Lincoln best—Phineas Gurley, the pastor of New York Avenue Presbyterian Church in Washington, which Lincoln regularly attended, and Methodist Bishop Matthew Simpson—said little about his personal faith. Gurley stressed that he had an “abiding confidence in the overruling providence of God.” Simpson emphasized that the president had “read the Bible frequently, loved . . . its profound teachings,” and sought to follow its precepts. He also claimed that Lincoln had sincerely striven to live by “the principles of revealed religion” and that no other ruler had shown as much “trust in God.”
To repeat, if Lincoln why not Obama?
American holy land and relics.
LikeLike
Bad link
LikeLike
Wow, Darryl has that kind of power, for TGC to pull things like that down off the web, that fast?
I’m impressed, yo.
LikeLike
Gotta love the webernet cache:
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:qfb8hGf3tXAJ:www.thegospelcoalition.org/blogs/justintaylor/2015/04/13/the-day-lincoln-was-shot-a-visual-faq/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=ubuntu
LikeLike
Chris, nice! Quick, take a print screen 🙂
LikeLike
I don’t get it, I just skimmed, but what was so objectionable that they took it down?
LikeLike
Todd, or maybe they just got their “cookies” mixed up and it’ll be back up.
That’s three. Peace.
LikeLike
But Obama is black. Just sayin’.
LikeLike
Wonder what the Coalition was thinking that had to do with the Gospel? Lincoln as co-belligerant?
LikeLike
And don’t forget that the Mormons are now claiming Lincoln. http://ldsliving.com/story/75704-did-lincoln-read-the-book-of-mormon
LikeLike
Everett, that’s interesting since the GOP wanted to abolish the two threats to Christian civilization — slavery and polygamy.
LikeLike
Search of Lincoln on TGC website yields 1870 results, some are mentions of Lincoln NE etc. but almost all are about President Lincoln. I don’t follow their site closely, but that many surprised me. I measure how much Americanism and historical naivete people have absorbed, by how they elevate Lincoln beyond a politician.
LikeLike
Todd, I doubt it came down due to this post or objectionable content. As AB mentioned, it was probably a technical glitch – I posted the cached version so people could enjoy the American holy land and relics tour Dr. Hart mentioned.
LikeLike
When I (all about me) visited the Lincoln Memorial, I had an eery feeling that I had never felt before.
The text written in the memorial begins with these words: “In this temple…”
Upon seeing the statute and reading those words, I had the distinct and unsettling impression of having trespassed w/in a pagan temple. I knew two things, 1) that this was a religious place, and 2) that this was not my religion — but one opposed to it.
American Civil Religion is not Christianity, but is an alternative to and opponent of Christianity. The Lincoln Memorial has more in common with the Temple of Artemis than with the Church. It is paganism dressed up in Sunday clothes.
LikeLike
proto—were there Jews writing ‘Land Letters’ to Assyrian politicians telling them what the Biblical worldview was regarding this war? Perhaps they wrote to the Egyptian allies? Did the Jews believe that the collapse of Assyria would somehow affect the Covenant? In fact did it really matter which Beast ruled over them? Granted some were better than others. Babylon probably was preferable to Assyria and Persia though still a Beast was even better
http://www.proto-protestantism.blogspot.com/2015/04/the-christian-response-to-bestial.html
LikeLike
Yay, Justin Taylor’s link works again. Gooooo “cookies!!”
LikeLike
To repeat, if Lincoln why not Obama?
Repeat? As usual, his commentariat has no bloody idea what the mysterious Oracle Hart is saying/not saying, nor did they the first time. Mostly they don’t give a spit either way, Darryl.
I find Old Life fascinating in form as a model-train version of Strauss’ Persecution and the Art of Writing: The Great Mind is leaving his esoteric messages, but unfortunately only for little toy men. [The full-size humans looking at the Old Life diorama can of course appreciate the exhibition.]
As for the substance, the historian can tell Lincoln from Obama as can the student of theology. Where Lincoln injected the Christian principle of healing and forgiveness into his deistic [meaning = not mentioning Christ] rhetoric, Obama clothes his
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moralistic_therapeutic_deism
in quasi-Christian rhetoric.
LikeLike
vd, t, what did Lincoln know about General Sherman and when did he know it as he doled out his principle of healing and forgiveness?
LikeLike
TVD, so you dont go to church (I get it – I probably wouldn’t go to church if I was in your camp, either). Do you at least read your Bible regularly?
Take care.
LikeLike
Hovering, brooding over inchoate darkness, Lincoln in his glory-presence-temple-archetype
LikeLike
A good blogger wrote some more on this topic:
And there’s more where that comes from.
LikeLike
DGH, your opinion of Harry Stout’s ” Upon The Altar of The Nation”? It was a heavy read for me, but at least I had a better idea after finishing it as to why people then and later took refuge in the explanations they found in popular {in today’s academy, civil) religion.
LikeLike
different Dan, I haven’t read it entirely. But I sympathetic to the argument. War sucks. The Civil War really sucked. Turning Lincoln into a martyr doesn’t do much for me.
LikeLike
How to mourn Lincoln’s death.
LikeLike
A “patriotic heresy“:
LikeLike