Boniface takes the temperature of Roman Catholicism in the light of Governor Cuomo and Archbishop Dolan:
the purpose of excommunication is not merely for the good of the sinner’s soul; it is also for the edification and protection of the community. “Do you not know that a little leaven leavens the whole lump? Cleanse out the old leaven that you may be a new lump.” St. Paul teaches that excommunication helps purge the body of “leaven”, and that without this purging such leaven will cause a rot throughout the body. When the offender is singled out and has judgment pronounced upon him, the faithful at least see that such behavior is proscripted. St. Paul is not only worried about the sinner, but about the boasting of the congregation, that is, their attitude about the sinner. By excommunicating him, St. Paul judges not only the sinner, but the broader attitude that allows sin to flourish unchecked.
To bring this back to Governor Cuomo: from the biblical perspective, whether Cuomo will repent or not, whether he respects the authority of the Church or not, whether the Church can claim any socio-political leverage in these matters, is not ultimately the main concern. The fact is, the good of the Catholic Church in America demands that this man be thrown out. At least make an attempt to purify the lump of its leaven. If we don’t, we are celebrating with the old leaven. It’s about the integrity of the community as much as it is about the sinner.
* * * * * *
There have often been times in Church history where discipline has been lost or seriously eroded. We can think of various monastic reforms throughout the centuries. Or the era of the Counter Reform and the Council of Trent when the Church had to fight an uphill battle to transform the episcopacy from a class of political courtiers into something more in line with what Christ intended. Countless regional synods from the first millennium and the era of the barbarian invasions attest to the Church’s commitment to maintaining or restoring discipline in an age of chaos when order seemed to be falling apart everywhere.
…And that’s the sad truth here. Cardinal Tobin, Dolan and the like don’t care what the optics are here. They don’t care whether the House of the Lord is an eye sore, an abomination to the people. “God’s name is blasphemed among the Gentiles because of you” (Rom. 2:24); but they don’t care. If discipline has been lost, then the common sense approach is to restore it. You restore it by making examples of people and actually asserting your will to enforce discipline. If you can’t do that or refuse to, it simply means you don’t even want discipline restored. You’re happy with the status quo. This is the inescapable conclusion: Cuomo will not face excommunication because the princes of the Church are content with the current situation.
So why convert? Protestants are supposed to think this is the church founded no matter how much it resembles mainline Protestantism? When the successors to the apostles are so far from following the apostles, we’re supposed to see nothing and come back to mother church?
4 thoughts on “Mainline Protestantism’s Elder Brother”
“ So why convert?“
Access to better teaching gigs.
b, sd, at Covington Catholic?
Since the 70s American Catholic conservatives have grumbled over the OCP (Oregon Catholic Press) missals that flooded Catholic hymnody with boomerish whateverism in the spirit of Vatican II; some of their worst offenders were literally written by mainline protestants.
For all of the arguments around papal encyclicals and the Catechism, Marty Haugen’s music is far more definitional of what it means to be Catholic in this country.
“The fact is, the good of the Catholic Church in America demands that this man be thrown out.” True, But what Boniface ignore is that the good of the Catholic Church also demanded 1) a defense of inerrancy, 2) a stress on missionary activity, and 3) jealousy for the integrity of its priests and liturgy. With all these already ignored, who really cares about Cuomo or Dolan. The damage is far upstream of their lover’s spat. But hey, lets all wax lyrical about Benedict XVI and St JPII the Great. Whatever.