Deaccession Files I: Erdman Being Erdman

The Deaccession Files will be a recurring series on older books from the era of J. Gresham Machen’s life that were acquired to build a library and now need to be deaccessed in preparation for new domestic arrangements following retirement.

Charles R. Erdman’s The Spirit of Christ (1926)

The podcasters at Presbycast have generated much amusement with the hashtag phrase, “Don’t Be An Erdman.” Those who admire and honor the work and career of J. Gresham Machen know intuitively the weight of this phrase since Charles Erdman, professor of practical theology at Princeton Theological Seminary (1905-1936) was Machen’s pain in the neck. Erdman was the pious evangelical who thought Machen’s polemics were mean. He was the seminary professor well connected to the officials who ran the Presbyterian Church USA’s agencies and could whisper to them what a bad fellow Machen was. Erdman was a successor to the New School Presbyterian tradition while teaching at an institution that had been decidedly Old School in ways Machen tried to perpetuate.

When I saw a free copy of Erdman’s Spirit of Christ almost thirty years ago, I took it and put it on my shelf for future reference partly because it was published in 1926 by the George H. Doran Company. The publisher itself is worthy of comment since Doran was a Canadian who in 1908 moved his firm to the United States and published a wide range of authors, among them Virginia Wolfe and H. L. Mencken. Doran merged with Doubleday a year after publishing Erdman’s book to become Doubleday, Doran. By 1946, Doubleday ghosted “Doran” to become Doubleday and Company. Some of which is to say, Doran as a publisher of a evangelical, premillennial Presbyterian is a mild surprise.

Because the period between 1923 and 1927 was peak Presbyterian controversy, with Machen and Erdman in Princeton and their loyalists at denominational gatherings very much at odds, a 1926 book from Erdman leads inevitably to questions whether he had Machen and the Presbyterian controversy in mind. The short answer is, he did.

From the opening paragraph of Erdman’s book, a reader who had followed the religious press would have no trouble concluding that the author was thinking about Machen when describing the ideal “follower of Christ.” A believer should manifest “in some degree the moral temper of his Master.” What characterized this temperament was “gentleness and courage,” “sympathy and strength,” and “purity and love.” Most of Erdman’s friends believed Machen was especially lacking in these graces. But if those attributes were vague in relation to Machen, Erdman’s second paragraph was telling: “A man may recite an orthodox creed and believe it, and yet be self-deceived as to his relation to Christ; he may be a defender of the faith. . . . and yet be a Pharisee.” A real believer “follows Christ, obeys Christ and reflects the character of Christ.”

So there!

Readers who used to listen to Presbycast may be surprised to learn that Erdman was fairly traditional, even Princetonian, on Scripture. When Peter suggested that the Holy Spirit was the author of sacred Scripture, he was indicating, according to Erdman, that inspiration by the third person of the Trinity was “the final explanation of [Scriptures’] unique character and supreme authority.” This doctrine did not involve a denial of the Bible’s human qualities or that God merely dictated the words of Scripture. But inspiration was true not because Benjamin Warfield was really smart but because the doctrine was precisely what the Bible taught. “These statements are direct and straightforward: ‘Holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Spirit.’ ‘God . . . spake in time past . . . by the prophets.’ ‘All scripture is given by inspiration of God,’ or ‘Every scripture inspired of God is also profitable for teaching,’ the reference being to the entire body of ‘sacred writings.’”

To add muscle to his defense of inspiration, Erdman even quoted from the Confession of Faith (1.5) in its entirety:

We may be moved and induced by the testimony of the church to an high and reverent esteem of the Holy Scripture. And the heavenliness of the matter, the efficacy of the doctrine, the majesty of the style, the consent of all the parts, the scope of the whole (which is, to give all glory to God), the full discovery it makes of the only way of man’s salvation, the many other incomparable excellencies, and the entire perfection thereof, are arguments whereby it doth abundantly evidence itself to be the Word of God: yet notwithstanding, our full persuasion and assurance of the infallible truth and divine authority thereof, is from the inward work of the Holy Spirit bearing witness by and with the Word in our hearts.

Erdman was less clear on the doctrine of salvation. In the chapter, “Filled with the Spirit,” he dipped into the Higher Life movement’s teachings that had spread among the circles cultivated by Dwight L. Moody and Hannah Whitall and Robert Smith. Erdman specifically explained the doctrine of the “Second Blessing,” the time of entire sanctification that came from a second work of the Spirit on a believer already justified through the first act of the Spirit. This second blessing did not necessarily have to wait for a later stage of Christian experience. If it was delayed, it was “the needless faulty and failure of the believer.” As odd as blaming the victim sounded, even stranger was Erdman’s acknowledgment that “being ‘filled with the Spirit’ is not a permanent state.” The example of the first disciples indicated their “repeatedly being ‘filled with the Spirit’; this implied fresh needs and an unfailing supply.”

The opposite of being filled with the Spirit was grieving the Holy Spirit. For Erdman, such offense was one of Machen’s faults. Theological controversy was especially perilous. “Fair, frank and kindly discussion of divergent views is stimulating and helpful, but bitterness, dogmatism and temper are destructive of spiritual power.” Erdman counseled all theological debaters to add a “vein of humor, common sense and brotherly love.” Later in the book he warned about dead orthodoxy: “There still are those who seem to feel that righteousness is embodied in ceremonial observance, or even in assent to an orthodox creed.” Such people counted themselves as Christian, “and even engage in religious activities, while their hearts are not right with God.” They were also “guilty of dishonesty, discourtesy, evny and ill will” toward “their fellow men.”

When Erdman discussed “spiritual childishness” you can also imagine how Machen came across. The professor of practical theology identified two signs of such immaturity. One was being “tossed to and from and carried about by every wind of doctrine.” For this reason, dogmatism was not a sign of spiritual maturity. Instead, “confident and abiding faith” was.

The second sign of spiritual immaturity was denominationalism. “‘Denominations’ may serve some temporary purpose,” but denominationalism always showed itself in “pride and narrowness and bigotry.” It was “always a hindrance to spiritual growth.” Division in the church were responsible for spiritual “impotence.” Erdman added that “a man who is factious, and causes separations among Christians, always retards the growth and edification of the church.”

A dip into Erdman’s Spirit of Christ provides any number of explanations for conflict between the author and his faculty colleague, Machen. It also suggests how stacked the deck was against Machen. Aside from any doctrinal irregularities like the second blessing, Erdman’s piety removed any day light between personal conviction and a common standard of truth. No wonder Machen struck Erdman as temperamentally defective. He lacked Erdman’s piety which in turn was supposed to be the standard for true devotion.

Historians who have questioned Machen’s personal defects have ironically followed Erdman’s standard of evaluation. Academics are supposed to be trained in methods of critical analysis. Many have applied such scrutiny to Machen but not to Erdman. Can’t someone at least acknowledge that an important difference separated the two Princeton professors and that determining guilt and innocence requires an agreed upon standard of evaluation. If the criteria wind up repeating Erdman’s view of dead orthodoxy, denominationalism, or spiritual childishness, then you many need to admit that you are being an Erdman.

Don’t be.

How not to Be an Erdman

Aside from being Machen’s nemesis, Charles Erdman was the son of a premillenialist and holiness Presbyterian evangelist who had close ties to Dwight Moody and the Keswick Conference (which stressed holiness as the biblical norm for sancification). Charles was also one of the editors of the series of pamphlets that historians associate with the origins of the fundamentalist movement. The Fundamentals were published between 1910 and 1915 and promoted some of the emphases that became associated with the 1920s opponents of theological liberalism. From all appearances, Erdman had “conservative” credentials. For historians who know very little about Old School Presbyterianism or the Princeton Theology, the spat between Erdman and Machen made no sense and so must have been the product of personal differences (read Machen’s idiosyncrasies). Why Princeton hired a premillennial professor of practical theology is another question.

For the pamphlet series, Erdman drew the straw to write on “The Church and Socialism,” not what you’d expect from a PT prof or a premillennialist. Here is part of what Erdman wrote:

This protest of Socialism is a call to the Church to proclaim more insistently the social principles of Christ. This does not mean the adoption of a so-called “social gospel” which discards the fundamental doctrines of Christianity and substitutes a religion of good works; but a true Gospel of grace is inseparable from a Gospel of good works. . . .

This protest of Socialism demands of the Church a more consistent practice, on the part of her members, of the social teachings of Christ. It is easy to bring false charges against Christians; it is even customary today to hold the Church up to ridicule and scorn as a society of hypocrites untrue to their professions and their Lord. It is not necessary to even consider these accusations which spring from ignorance or prejudice or spite. The great masses of Christians are striving to be faithful and seeking to live well-pleasing to their Master. However, it is true that there are some in the Church who are consciously guilty of sins against society, and others who, because of the difficulty of the questions involved, excuse themselves on the ground that their wrong practices are necessitated by the industrial system of the age. Some are quite comfortable under w what they regard as orthodox preaching, even though they know their wealth has come from the watering of stocks and from wrecking railroads, and from grinding the faces of the poor. . . .

The protest of Socialism is a distinct call to the Church to define anew to herself her function, and to interpret anew the prophecies of her Lord.
There are many who, in the name of Christianity, have been promising a new social order, a kingdom of God, which they declare the Church will
introduce. The long continued failure to realize these promises has led to criticisms of the Church, and has done not a little to increase the bitterness of socialistic attacks upon her. The Church is now being held responsible for social sins and injustice, for the wrongs and grievances of the age; and for this unfortunate position she must largely blame herself. She has arrogated functions which are not her own; she has made promises for which there is no written word of Scripture. It should be remembered, for instance, that the state is quite as purely a divine institution as is the Church. It is for the state to secure social reconstruction when necessary; it is for the state to punish offenders, and to secure by legal enactments and legislative processes the abolition of abuses, and the establishment of justice. When the Church assumes functions belonging to the state, she involves herself in needless difficulties and places herself in a false position before the world. . . . but the real blessedness of the Church and of the world awaits the personal return of Christ. The hope of the world is not in a new social order instituted by unregenerate men; not a millennium made by man; not a commonwealth of humanity organized as a Socialistic state; but a kingdom established by Christ which will fill the earth with glory at the coming of the King.

That is an odd mix of progressive politics, spirituality of the church, and premillennialism.

That contrasts with what Machen wrote about socialism for the Christian Reformed Churches, The Banner, in an exchange about the Child Labor Amendment:

What, at bottom, is the difference between the ethics of socialism and the ethics of Christianity? In some ways the two look very much alike. Both are seeking to relive creature distress; and both require men of wealth, at least under certain circumstances, to give up their wealth and become poor. But the socialist seeks to accomplish that by force, and the Christian seeks to accomplish it by love. There lies the profound difference. The socialist says to the man who possesses this worlds’s goods: “We intend to compel you to distribute your wealth as we see fit: we should regard ourselves as degraded if we received it from you as a gift, but we intend to take it from you by force.” The Christian, on the other hand, says to the man of wealth, or rather to the man who has any amount, large or small, for this world’s good: “the Lord loveth a cheerful giver; will you not have compassion upon those less fortunate than yourself; and will you not take any possible sting of degradation from the receivers of such a gift by letting your gift be prompted truly by love?” I think there is a deep-seated conflict between these two views of life; I do not think that that conflict between them can permanently be concealed. (“Voices in the Church,” 391-92)

Why Presbyterians Are Ambivalent about Evangelicals

Chris Gerhz is a good historian and generally thoughtful about a number of matters (even when you disagree), but his piece about the virtues of mainline Protestantism is an indication of how thin the ties are within the bond of evangelical Protestantism. In the post, he is frank about the mainline’s numerical decline and mentions a few reasons for it. But Gehrz also mentions several features of the mainline that he appreciates and would hate to go away. First up, women’s ordination:

In an inscription on the balcony in our sanctuary, the Apostle Paul reminds us that it is by “the power of the Holy Spirit” that we “may abound in hope” (Rom 15:13). Truly, I have hope for the renewal of the ELCA, the mainline, and all the church, because I trust that God’s Spirit continues to move in our midst: comforting, counseling, and gifting us to accomplish more than we can imagine.

Whenever I need to be reminded of that truth, I turn my head to the right of the choir loft, where I see the two women who serve as our senior and associate pastors preaching the Word and administering the sacraments. Then I think of the women on our staff who direct the church’s excellent children and youth ministries. And while I don’t put a lot of credence in church hierarchies, I may even recall that women currently serve as the bishop of our local synod and as the denomination’s presiding bishop.

In a time when most (non-Pentecostal) evangelical denominations deny such roles to women or fail to back up egalitarian words with regular calls to pastoral ministry and leadership, it’s the mainline that best embodies the Pentecost message that God has poured out his spirit on all humanity, such that daughters and sons alike will speak for him.

Say what you will about the significance of women’s ordination — some could conceivably liken it to Sabbath-Day desecration, which is hardly an offense worthy of ecclesiastical discipline in the Presbyterian world — but what sort of support might a fellow like Gehrz render to fellow Presbyterians if he were in a common endeavor with them? Chances are if a vote came up about recognizing a female pastor or an organization’s ties to a communion that ordained women, Gehrz would vote with mainline Protestants against those Presbyterian communions that refuse office to women. That’s not inherently bad. But it makes difficult the thought that an Orthodox Presbyterian and an evangelical Pietist-turned-mainline-Lutheran could meaningfully cooperate in so-called Christian organizations.

Gehrz also appreciates the mainline’s ecumenical posture:

Here I don’t so much mean the institutional ecumenism of the National and World Councils of Churches as the lived faith of congregations like ours, where we’re regularly reminded both of our Lutheran distinctiveness and our participation in the unity of the church catholic….

“Go in peace,” we’re told at the end of worship, “and serve the Lord.” That’s a charge we can only fulfill together, with Christians who might belong and believe differently than us. During Sunday’s education hour, we learned about our church’s partnership with Dorothy Day Place, which continues that Catholic writer’s commitment to living in solidarity with the poor. The week before, children of all ages had assembled materials for Bridging, a local nonprofit that helps Minnesotans transition out of homelessness; its Catholic founder had died the day before.

There goes the spirituality of the church (or the idea that the church provides services — chiefly spiritual and eternal — that non-government agencies or government welfare can). When the idea of Christian unity comes from race, class, and gender, what’s a Presbyterian to do about the Shorter Catechism or the regulative principle of worship?

Finally, Gehrz thinks the mainline has contributed well to congregational singing and liturgical music (it is hard to disagree, especially if evangelicalism is known primarily for Praise & Worship worship music):

In Paul’s much-debated passage on the mutual submission that marks a united church, he also describes being “filled with the Spirit” in these terms: “you sing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs among yourselves, singing and making melody to the Lord in your hearts, giving thanks to God the Father at all times and for everything in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ” (Eph 5:19).

Of course, there are many ways of living this out in practice. We all have our own preferences. You won’t be surprised that an evangelical who laments the removal of hymnals is no fan of worship that takes its cue from megachurches, where the congregation is too often reduced to a passive audience standing silent as professional performers sing words that are too shallow to the accompaniment of tunes that are too monotonous. …

Of course, “traditional” worship has its own problems. … But at its vibrant, creative best, such worship embodies Pelikan’s definition of tradition (“the living faith of the dead”). For example, my heart swells as the centuries-old words of Nicolai’s Epiphany chorale again “teach us / God’s own love through you has reached us.” And it’s worth pointing out that five of the eight texts our congregation or choir sang in that single hour of worship were written by authors born in the 20th century. This, too, is living tradition: Christian composers and writers continuing to adapt old musical forms to accompany still older words (mostly from Scripture itself)… and Christian laypeople continuing to sing them, actively participating in worship. (Many of them even singing in four-part harmony, another way we may learn Christian unity.)

That this happens is not the result of mere inertia. It has taken the conscious, ongoing investment of mainline churches in publishing houses that encourage musical creativity and in colleges that provide musical training for professionals and amateurs alike.

At this point, Gerhz might appreciate the OPC and URC’s cooperation in producing a Psalter-Hymnal, an expression of Reformed Protestantism’s tradition of congregational song. What is unclear is how interest in the past when it comes to worship fits with the relative recentness of ideas about ordaining women and the social gospel. It actually looks like the mainline tradition, as it appeals to some evangelicals, is a relatively arbitrary collection of ideals and convictions — good taste when it comes to music, overturning hierarchies when it comes to gender and class.

To his credit, Gehrz concedes that mainline Protestantism can go wrong:

Beautiful music can become the end of worship, rather than one of its means. Practiced for its own sake, ecumenism easily turns bureaucratic or latitudinarian. And the conviction that the Spirit is bringing renewal can tempt us to exchange dead orthodoxy for living heterodoxy.

But I don’t suspect he will want any help from confessional Presbyterians in spotting if and when the mainline veers from orthodox norms.

Which makes me wonder again why conservative Presbyterians ever thought they would get much in return for joining forces with so-called evangelicals. Heck, it looks like evangelicals — think Charles Erdman — resonate more with liberal Protestantism than with confessional Protestantism. It is another variety of third-way Christianity — neither modernist nor historic. But always with a nod to the Holy Spirit. Just not too much like those crazy Pentecostals.